Key Differences Between Class A and Class B Fire Doors: A Comprehensive Guide As a leading fire door manufacturer in China, we understand that choosing the right fire door is crucial for ensuring safety and compliance with national standards. In this article, we will explore the fundamental differences between Class A fire doors and Class […]
Tag Archives: The difference between different levels of fire doors
Differences Between Fire Door Ratings (30/60/90/120/180 Minutes)
Fire doors are classified by their fire resistance duration, which indicates how long they can withstand fire exposure while maintaining integrity (E), insulation (I), and smoke control (S). Below is a detailed comparison of different fire door levels based on international standards (GB 12955, EN 1634, UL 10C).
1. Fire Door Rating Levels & Standards
Rating (Minutes) | Standard (China – GB 12955) | EU (EN 1634) | USA (UL 10C) | Common Applications |
---|---|---|---|---|
30 min | 丙级 (Grade C) | EI30 | 20/30 min | Offices, storage rooms |
60 min | 乙级 (Grade B) | EI60 | 45/60 min | Hospitals, schools |
90 min | 甲级 (Grade A) | EI90 | 90 min | Stairwells, high-rises |
120 min | 甲级 (Grade A) | EI120 | 120 min | Industrial, factories |
180 min | 甲级 (Grade A) | EI180 | 180 min | Nuclear plants, labs |
Key Terms:
-
E (Integrity) – No flames/heat penetration.
-
I (Insulation) – Unexposed side stays below 140°C.
-
S (Smoke Control) – Blocks smoke leakage (≤25m³/h·m²).
2. Construction & Material Differences
A. Core Materials
Rating | Core Material | Thickness | Density |
---|---|---|---|
30 min | Gypsum board | 35–45mm | ≥80kg/m³ |
60 min | Mineral wool | 40–50mm | ≥110kg/m³ |
90 min | Vermiculite board | 45–55mm | ≥130kg/m³ |
120+ min | Ceramic fiber | 50–70mm | ≥150kg/m³ |
B. Steel Skin Thickness
-
30–60 min doors: 0.8–1.2mm steel
-
90–180 min doors: 1.2–2.0mm steel (reinforced edges)
C. Intumescent Seals
-
30 min: Basic graphite strips (expand at 200°C)
-
60+ min: Multi-layer seals (expand 5–10x size)
-
120+ min: Ceramic-based seals (withstand 1000°C+)
3. Performance Under Fire Exposure
Rating | Furnace Temp | Failure Criteria |
---|---|---|
30 min | 840°C | No flames for 30 min |
60 min | 925°C | Unexposed side <140°C |
90 min | 980°C | No structural collapse |
120 min | 1050°C | Must pass hose stream test |
180 min | 1150°C | No heat transfer for 3h |
Hose Stream Test (ASTM E119 / EN 1363-2)
-
After fire exposure, doors must withstand a water jet blast without failing.
4. Hardware Requirements
Component | 30–60 min Doors | 90–180 min Doors |
---|---|---|
Hinges | 3 x stainless steel | 4 x heavy-duty steel |
Locks | Standard fire-rated | Multi-point locking |
Closers | Adjustable (EN 1154) | Heavy-duty (EN 1155) |
Seals | Single-layer intumescent | Double-layer + smoke seal |
5. Where Each Rating Is Used?
A. 30-Minute Doors (Grade C / EI30)
-
Use: Low-risk areas (storage rooms, offices)
-
Features:
-
Basic fire resistance
-
Lightweight (40–50kg)
-
Lower cost
-
B. 60-Minute Doors (Grade B / EI60)
-
Use: Residential buildings, schools, hospitals
-
Features:
-
Balances cost & safety
-
Better smoke sealing
-
C. 90-Minute Doors (Grade A / EI90)
-
Use: Stairwells, elevator lobbies, high-rises
-
Features:
-
High-security reinforcement
-
Required in fire escape routes
-
D. 120–180-Minute Doors (EI120/EI180)
-
Use:
-
Oil & gas facilities
-
Nuclear plants
-
Data centers
-
-
Features:
-
Extreme heat resistance
-
Bulletproof options available
-
6. Cost Comparison
Rating | Price Range (USD) | Cost Factors |
---|---|---|
30 min | $300–$600 | Basic materials |
60 min | $500–$900 | Better seals |
90 min | $800–$1,500 | Reinforced core |
120+ min | $1,500–$3,000 | Specialized materials |
7. Which Rating Do You Need?
-
Residential: 60 min (EI60)
-
Commercial: 90 min (EI90)
-
Industrial: 120–180 min (EI120/EI180)
Always check local building codes (NFPA, IBC, GB 50016).
Conclusion
Higher-rated fire doors provide longer protection but cost more due to thicker steel, advanced cores, and better seals. Choose based on building type, fire risk, and regulations.